2010-09-09
More Comments on Good to Great
This study was stimulated by Mr. Bill Meehan’s (head of McKinsey in San Francisco) observation that Built to Last wasn’t very helpful to companies, because the firms studied had always been great. Most companies have been good, and never great. What should these firms do?
Jim Collins and his team have done an enormous amount of interesting work to determine whether a good company can be come a great company, and how. The answer to the former question is “yes,” assuming that the 11 of 1435 Fortune 500 companies did not make it there by accident. The answer to the latter is less clear. The study group identified a number of characteristics that their 11 companies had in common, which were much less frequently present in comparison companies. However, the study inexplicably fails to look at these same characteristics to see how often they succeed in the general population of companies. If these characteristics work 100 percent of the time, you really have something. If they work 5 percent of the time, then not too much is proven.
How were the 11 study companies selected? The criteria take pages to explain in an appendix. Let me simplify by saying that their stock price growth had to be in a range from somewhat lower than to not much higher than the market averages for 15 years. Then, in the next 15 years the stocks had to soar versus the market averages and comparison companies while remaining independent. That’s hard to do. The selected companies are Abbott Laboratories, Circuit City, Fannie Mae, Gillette, Kimberly-Clark, Kroger, Nucor, Philip Morris, Pitney Bowes, Walgreen, and Wells Fargo.
As to the “how,” attention was focused on what happened before and during the transition from average performance to high performance. Interviews, quantitative analyses, and business press reports were studied. Clearly, there’s a tendency to see things a little bit with 20-20 hindsight in such a situation. Since this study started in 1996, it was dealing with facts that were already quite old while they were being examined. Bias is likely.
The key conclusions as to “how” included the following:
(1) a series of CEOs (promoted from within) who combined “personal humility and professional will” focused on making a great company;
(2) an initial focus on eliminating weak people, adding top performing ones, and establishing a culture of top talent putting out extraordinary effort;
(3) then shifting attention to staring at and thinking unceasingly about the hardest facts about the company’s situation;
(4) using facts to develop a simple concept that is iteratively reconsidered to focus action on improving performance;
(5) establishing and maintaining a corporate culture of discipline built around commitments, with freedom about how to meet those promises;
(6) using technology to accelerate progress when it fits the company’s concept of what it wants to become; and
(7) the company builds momentum from consistent efforts behind its concept that are reinforced by success.
Then, a connection is made to how these 7 conditions can provide the foundation for establishing a Built to Last type of company that can outperform the competition over many decades.
One potential criticism of the study is that its conclusions could be dated. Former Stanford professor Collins argues that he has uncovered basic facts about human organizations that will be unchanging.
I compared the conclusions in this book with my own studies of top performing CEOs and companies in the 1988-2001 time period. I noticed two major differences that suggest a shift in “best practice” standards. First, those who outperform now have developed processes that create major improvements in their operating business models every 2-5 years. Second, senior management development is focused around improving a culture for defining and implementing such improvements. I suspect that item (4) above was an embryonic predecessor to these new dimensions, which occur much more frequently now than in this study.
Next, I compared the list of 7 items to what I had observed in companies. The biggest point that hit me is how few CEOs have been interested in creating long-term outperformance that lasts past their own tenure in an industry. You also have to be a CEO for a long time with that focus before you have a chance to make a lasting impact. Founders have a special advantage here. Perpetuating outperformance may help fill a psychological need for immortality that fits with founders especially well.
Finally, I thought about what I knew about the companies studied from personal contacts during the study years. My sense is that their stories are far more complex than is captured here. So, I think the data have probably been “scrunched” to fit together in some cases. In particular, I wonder whether these companies will greatly outperform in the next 15 years. In many cases, they expanded to meet an unfilled need that is now largely fulfilled. Can they develop a new concept for (4) that will carry them forward as successfully in the future? My guess is that most will not. If that turns out to be the case, we must conclude that the items on this list may be necessary . . . but may not be sufficient to go permanently from good to great. Time will tell.
Before closing, let me observe that if the research team had also looked at the rate by which their principles succeeded among companies that employed them, this would have been one of the very finest research studies on best practices that I have seen. A book like this will provoke much discussion and thought for years to come. Perhaps that information can be included in a future edition or printing. Then, we will have something magnificent to consider!
Do you want to be the best permanently? Why? Or, why not? Mr. Collins points out that it probably takes no more effort, but a lot more discipline and focus.
1
Comments
More Comments On Good To Great News
Sep
09
Sep
08
The Joker is no joke on way to Open semifinals ... maybe more? - CBSSports.com
2010-09-08
CBSSports.comThe Joker is no joke on way to Open semifinals ... maybe more?CBSSports.com(AP) He has done impersonations of everyone from Rafael Nadal to Maria Sharapova, has given comments on almost anything and once again has given himself a ...and more »Sep
08
What they said: Tiger Woods - PGA Tour
2010-09-08
What they said: Tiger WoodsPGA TourLet's get your comments on being back. TIGER WOODS: Yeah, it's good to be back. It's even better to be in the event. So it's good to be here. ...and more »
Sep
08
Tom Brady on the Bengals - Cincinnati.com (blog)
2010-09-08
ReutersTom Brady on the BengalsCincinnati.com (blog)He throws the ball extremely accurately, makes good decisions, great leader, has great command. He can make all the throws, very athletic, tough. ...No more distractions for Pats QBNashua TelegraphDodge ballAttleboro Sun ChronicleMailbag: Doubt heading into opener?ESPNMilford Daily News -Boston Herald -WEEI.comall 679 news articles »Sep
08
Review: Ping a handy iTunes add-on with promise - The Associated Press
2010-09-08
Review: Ping a handy iTunes add-on with promiseThe Associated PressI'm sure this generates more page views and, yes, advertising revenue for Live Nation Entertainment Inc., which now owns both sites. ...and more »Sep
09
Overhaul law may boost health spending only slightly, report says - The State
2010-09-09
Overhaul law may boost health spending only slightly, report saysThe State"This is great news for the millions of individuals and families who have struggled with the high cost of coverage," DeParle wrote. "More good news for ...and more »Sep
07
The Difference Between Good Design and Great Design
2010-09-07
What's the difference between a good design and a great design? It's all a matter of perspective. ... Though one of these goals is bound to be aesthetics, it is often the case that the final product is a less-attractive but more on-target version of what you originally presented. As an example of a good client-focused design, consider the site below. screenshot. Here we see both perspectives at work. First of all, the designer has created a really great-looking site (not ...Sep
05
Robert Kuttner: Not Just Jobs -- Good Jobs
2010-09-05
Comments 504. On Labor Day 2010, we are short at least 25 million jobs. And just as importantly, we don't have enough jobs that pay decently. The press last week was full of stories that the jobs picture was not as dismal as feared. ... The Obama administration has made some heartening steps in both directions, but it could do a great deal more. Federal procurement, directly or indirectly, affects about one fourth of the jobs in the economy. In past administrations ...Sep
07
Simon Maxwell Apter: Wanted: One Good Burrito
2010-09-07
check out www.burritoeater.com for lots of great burrito joints. burritophile is a good look too. g. garnet_timothy_harry: check out www.burritoeater.com for lots of great burrito joints. burritophile. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/ garnet_timothy_harry/wanted-one-good-burrito_b_706739_59803756.html. Permalink | Share it. There are More Comments on this Thread. Click Here To See them All. lakat 10 hours ago (3:13 PM) ...Sep
08
HuffPost TV: Arianna On Olbermann: Obama's Ohio Speech The Best ...
2010-09-08
Obama is like a plumber that comes over to your house, gives you a very good, detailed explanation of what the problem is and then leaves. You look around and the toilet is still clogged and the pipes are still leaking. .... Bados: Thats your pained way of saying great job to your. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/Bados/arianna-on-olbermann-obama-boehner-speech_b_709936_59903988.html. Permalink | Share it. There are More Comments on this Thread. ...Sep
07
What's Up With Hodgson? Nobody Really Knows - Orland Kurtenblog
2010-09-07
More importantly, is CH motivated by these comments? Didn't think so. It's AV's problem. His neanderthal attitude. He will ruin more good young prospects than any other factor. Can the "nux afford to let AV's ego poison their future? Didn't think so. ... Cody is great, his back according to Roberts is not an issue at all. Apparently he is going to fly through physicals next week. Roberts noted to the media last week he has never scene a kid his age with legs that strong. ...Hedgehog Concepts
Using the Hedgehog Concept to Find Your Business Sweet Spot
Navigation
Related Searches
